Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

'Git' is a preexisting word; it'd be pretty strange to pronounce it with a soft G.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/git#Etymology_1

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/git#Etymology_2

It'd be like naming your software fukr and then insisting "no no no, the R is pronounced 'are', not 'er'."



Git' is a preexisting word; it'd be pretty strange to pronounce it with a soft G.

It certainly was when I heard it.


I work with a French guy who uses "szheet"


As opposed to "age"?


No, "age" is not only a preexisting word, it's one that's common as dirt.

Having the rust port be "rage" only compounds the problem.

The author's rather Italian-looking name tends to suggest that he wouldn't view a hard G as a possibility for the word "age" either (and the pronunciation link specifically goes to a synthetic Italian pronunciation of the word "aghe"...), so something else is going on.


I don't understand how the author wants to pronounce it. "ag-ay"? It's very confusing that it's an extremely common word which this program decides to pronounce differently.


> I don't understand how the author wants to pronounce it. "ag-ay"?

More or less. In the technical specifics, the English FACE vowel is a diphthong ending at a pretty high point ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vowel#Height ), whereas the indicated pronunciation is a monophthong that should be a bit lower.

You might think of the English vowels in FACE / PRICE / CHOICE / GOAT / MOUTH as being "closed off" by a rapid upward tongue movement towards the end of their pronunciation; what the author is asking for here is a version of "FACE" that doesn't have that closure. Or, alternatively, a version of DRESS [which is already a monophthong] that uses a bit higher of a tongue position.


Or Coq?


Coq is pronounced exactly how it looks. It's the French word for rooster and for the language, comes from part of the guy's name.


> It's the French word for rooster

It's also the English word for rooster.


Well, cock is. Coq is not an English word.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: