Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Seven hours in, all comments assume this is to screw the car owner.

But FTA:

BMW really does want to use these to stop people from working on their own cars. It spells out in the patent that "the shape of the engagement recesses prevents the screw from being loosened or tightened using common counter-drive structures, e.g. by unauthorized persons." That's straight from BMW.

The second sentence is key: "unauthorized" can be woke-speak for thief, and this device doesn't seem to require a single key per car which has been a PITA for VW/BMW in the past.

The first sentence can then be edited to simply:

BMW really does want to use these to stop people from removing wheels from cars they don't own.

Before you object the thieves will just go get the tool: professionals yes, opportunistic, no.

This is enough of a real issue in some places there's a discount on theft insurance for car contents and parts when you have wheel theft prevention devices (e.g. wheel or hub locks). Granted, the insurers might not see this as actuarially meaningful, it might just be extra revenue from people who care about their wheels, but then you'd expect to see it everywhere.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: