Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This whole WiFi motion sensing is totally new to me. If anyone else is in the same boat reading this here are some details I found.

https://g.co/gemini/share/87f17617ca29

The interesting bits from the search are below. —- Wi-Fi 7 (802.11be), also known as Extremely High Throughput (EHT), brings significant advancements that are highly beneficial for Wi-Fi sensing applications, including motion detection, and can potentially offer a higher degree of accuracy and more advanced capabilities compared to Wi-Fi 6E. While Xfinity's Wi-Fi Motion currently relies on XB7 (Wi-Fi 6) and XB8 (Wi-Fi 6E) gateways, future iterations or third-party solutions built on Wi-Fi 7 would leverage its new features. Here's how Wi-Fi 7 enhances motion detection and sensing: Key Wi-Fi 7 Features Relevant to Sensing: * Ultra-wide 320 MHz Channels: * Impact on Sensing: Wi-Fi 7 supports channel widths up to 320 MHz, exclusively in the 6 GHz band (twice the maximum width of Wi-Fi 6E). Wider channels mean more subcarriers in the OFDM signal. This translates to much richer and higher-resolution Channel State Information (CSI). More data points in the CSI allow for finer-grained detection of signal perturbations caused by motion, potentially leading to: * More precise localization: Better ability to pinpoint where motion is occurring. * Detection of more subtle movements: Including micro-motions like breathing or heartbeats (as seen in advanced research). * Improved filtering: Better differentiation between human motion, pets, or environmental noise. * Multi-Link Operation (MLO): * Impact on Sensing: MLO allows devices to transmit and receive data simultaneously across multiple frequency bands (2.4 GHz, 5 GHz, and 6 GHz) or channels within the same band. * Benefits for Sensing: * Increased Robustness: If one link experiences interference or fades, sensing can continue on another link, improving reliability. * Enhanced Coverage and Accuracy: By aggregating data from multiple links, the system gets a more comprehensive view of the signal environment, leading to better motion detection coverage and accuracy, especially in complex environments. * Potential for 3D Sensing: Combining information from multiple links and bands could facilitate more sophisticated 3D tracking of objects or people. * 4096-QAM (Quadrature Amplitude Modulation): * Impact on Sensing: 4K QAM allows each symbol to carry more bits of data (12 bits compared to 10 bits in Wi-Fi 6/6E's 1024-QAM). While primarily for throughput, higher-order modulation requires incredibly clean and stable signals. * Benefits for Sensing: The underlying ability of Wi-Fi 7 to maintain such high modulation rates implies a network that is extremely sensitive to signal integrity. This sensitivity can be leveraged for sensing, as even tiny changes in the environment (due to motion) would cause discernible shifts in the highly modulated signal, potentially making detection more precise. * Improved MU-MIMO (Multi-User Multiple Input Multiple Output) and Increased Spatial Streams: * Impact on Sensing: Wi-Fi 7 increases the number of spatial streams (up to 16x16 MU-MIMO compared to 8x8 in Wi-Fi 6/6E). * Benefits for Sensing: More spatial streams mean more diverse signal paths are being transmitted and received. This provides even richer and more redundant CSI data, which is invaluable for robust and accurate sensing, particularly for distinguishing multiple targets or for fine-grained motion analysis. * Spectrum Puncturing and Multi-RU Allocation: * Impact on Sensing: These features allow for more flexible and efficient use of spectrum, even in the presence of interference. * Benefits for Sensing: By intelligently avoiding interfered portions of a wide channel, the system can maintain cleaner CSI data from the usable subcarriers, ensuring more consistent sensing performance in noisy environments. * Lower Latency: * Impact on Sensing: Wi-Fi 7 significantly reduces latency. * Benefits for Sensing: Lower latency means faster processing and reporting of motion events. This is crucial for real-time applications like security alerts, fall detection, or gesture recognition where immediate response is critical. Applications and Potential Accuracy of Wi-Fi 7 for Sensing: With these advancements, Wi-Fi 7 has the potential to push Wi-Fi sensing beyond simple presence detection to more sophisticated applications: * Highly Accurate Presence and Motion Detection: More reliable detection of human presence (even stationary) and movement within a defined area. * Precise Localization and Tracking: Better ability to identify the exact position of a person or object and track their movement paths within a space. * Gesture Recognition: Potential for recognizing specific human gestures for control applications (e.g., smart home controls without touch). * Biometric Sensing: More accurate detection of subtle physiological signals like breathing patterns and heart rate, which has applications in elder care, sleep monitoring, and health tracking, all without wearable devices. * People Counting: Improved ability to accurately count the number of people in a room. * Enhanced Security: More robust detection of intruders and fewer false alarms compared to earlier Wi-Fi sensing iterations. While the "degree of accuracy" is hard to quantify with a single number (as it depends on the specific implementation, algorithms, and environment), Wi-Fi 7's core features provide a much stronger foundation for building highly accurate, reliable, and advanced Wi-Fi sensing solutions compared to Wi-Fi 6/6E. It moves Wi-Fi sensing closer to the capabilities of dedicated radar or mmWave sensors in certain contexts, while leveraging existing Wi-Fi infrastructure.






If you had a particular idea from the LLM that you wanted to share people would be more receptive, but just dumping the whole output comes across as intellectually lazy

Please don't do this. Whether it's LLM-generated or not, we don't want big blocks of text from elsewhere pasted into comments here. Please at least try to craft original human thoughts.



Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: