Trusting your gut isn't a useful debate tactic, but it is a useful tool for everybody to use personally. Different people will come to different conclusions, and that's fine. Finding a universal consensus about future predictions will never happen, it's an unrealistic goal. The point of the discussion isn't to create a consensus; it's useful because listening to people with other opinions can shed light on some blind spots all of us have, even if we're pretty sure the other guys are wrong about all or most of what they're saying.

FWIW my gut happens to agree with yours.