I meant it only for the reported content so that is, to me, a proper balance because that's kind of your legal requirement[0] to take down content which is reported. But since that's ripe for abuse the proper way is to basically first hide the content, review+confirm it's bad, and then take proper action.

So I would try asking around or thinking of how best to handle the specific reported cases without exposing yourself too directly.

[0]: I am not a lawyer