Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The reason why no engineer has made this yet, is because the medical data was not available to them.

The innovation is in the data, not in the ML.




You are wrong. The kid GREW FUNGUS IN ARTIFICIAL LUNGS using a sterile field made out of a plastic bin with dish gloves cut into it. He didn't need medical data. Anyone could have done this- anyone with the intelligence and creativity that this kid has.


is it possible you're overstating what the kid did a bit here? The history of sterile fields shows that even great scientists take decades to debug contamination that causes false positives and negatives. ASn experiment like this can be easily thrown off by any number of variables that weren't carefully controlled for.


You need medical data if you want to validate your results for a real medical disorder.

Fabrication of data is not very useful if you have to gather data for validation anyway.


> The innovation is in the data, not in the ML.

can't you kind of say this about all ML? That the main driver in ML is 99% the quality of the training data and 1% the specific details of the neural networks used?


For most real-world applications of ML, yes. Of course, what happens in ML-research is different (where e.g. new networks for new modalities are invented).

But back to the topic, I bet the kid didn't even invent their own neural network topology, but just pulled a predefined network from a library, perhaps without even knowing it. Which is ok, because that is how most people use ML.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: