Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They can switch to Android.

The App Store protections are part of the platform value proposition. Please don't respond with "they don't have to install third party store" nonsense, because for many people if (say) google docs puts itself in its own store they will have no choice.



Microsoft really should have used this defense back in the 90s.

What, you don't like Internet Explorer? Apple exists, buy a Mac! Or better yet, delete Windows and install Linux! See, there's no monopolistic behavior at all, provided that number of competitors is greater than zero!


> Microsoft really should have used this defense back in the 90s.

They did. They were pointing to MacOS and Sun Solaris and all of them as supposed competitors, even though they didn't run on the same hardware as Windows did and apps for Windows didn't run on them.

The court didn't buy it.


And in the same way 'they can switch to Android', people could switch to any other Office suite on iOS. If you truly believe that people are choosing Apple for the "App Store protections", then why would they move off? Every third party app store would fail instantly.

It's because other app stores are providing better value or better apps? Well that's why Apple preventing other app stores is anti-competitive.

If someone picks Apple over Android is being of value and therefore should be allowed, how is someone picking Google Docs over every other Apple App Store office suite not also because of value?


Hold on, you can use your iOS apps that you paid for on Android now? And access iCloud? And use iMessage?

Oh wait, you mean give up all that stuff to 'switch to android'. To most people that like suggesting that they learn how to write with their left hand by cutting off their right hand; Not even close to tenable.


They could be free to put sideloading behind 10 warning/error flags, in which case google docs would be effectively forced to use the still de facto AppStore.

Yet I still get the opportunity to install whatever program I want to on a device I payed a huge sum of money.

And no, switching between 2 things is not consumer choice, so with all due respect, saying switching to android is disrespectful.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: