Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | bestouff's commentslogin

Well, AI already sends your code to US so ...

Most AI only sends a limited context. These are sending all files it can access as well as all edits.

> These are sending all files it can access

TBF, Cursor's code indexing works the same way, it has to send all workspace files to their servers.

Auto-completion systems need previous edits to suggest next edits so no surprises their either.


Yes because there's no difference between a voluntary service with limited context needs and a malicious extension

Cursor is a malicious extension though, and nobody seems to care.

“I donate money to animal shelters”

“Oh that’s cool, I already donate to my local neo nazi group. We are both philanthropists!”

Nothing makes me go from apolitical to a red blooded American faster than seeing someone make a stupid false equivalency about the US on this forum


It wasn't China that recently threatened with an invasion of Greenland (I'm Danish). That being said, it's not like you would want your data to go to either countries.

Yeah man, you said it best, we don’t want data going to either government. I’m just not sure Cursor is affiliated with the government.

Also, sorry about the whole US threat thing. Nobody I know on the ground here is happy with how we look on the world stage.


You did hear about Snowden and the massive NSA data collection ? That was almost 20 years ago, think about what it's like now: they probably use our data to run an elaborate simulation of everyone.

Yeah, I’m not against the guy I was replying to at all. I don’t want my data in any government coffers. The false equivalency of state sponsored threats in China to a private American company just triggered me.

I’m definitely with you on the nightmare hellscape that is being cooked up by the NSA.


Shocking news: not everybody here is from the US.

In fact, many even are from "hostile countries" that are "enemies of democracy".

What's more, some of those people aren't aligned with US interests and aren't willing to put their lives on the line for CIA operations!


... and Canada doesn't seem very keen on going on like this.


Yeah, assuming Canada is just going to keep going along buying American software and services seems pretty naive. There's less capacity to build alternatives in Canada than there is in Europe, but as Europe builds out alternative ecosystems, Canadians will likely be just as eager customers as Europeans (if not more eager).

The beauty of so many of these solutions being open source solutions also means that it creates avenues for cooperation between organizations that have no official cooperation agreement.

E.g. The Austrian federal Military, the state of Schleswig-Holstein, and the city of Leon have no direct forum for cooperating on software projects, yet all three are contributing to the development and rapid adoption of Nextcloud. Canada can easily get in on this too.


Canada has roughly the population of California, and Aus/NZ combined have populations less than California. For these types of market analyses, these countries are closer to US states in market potential.


Sure.

Canada has a GDP of:

Kansas, Arkansas, Nebraska, Mississippi, New Mexico, Idaho, New Hampshire, Hawaii, West Virginia, Delaware, Maine, Rhode Island, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Alaska, Wyoming and Vermont

put together.

That's the equivalent of 18 states.

Throw in Aus and NZ too and you add another 7 states -- Louisiana, Alabama, Utah, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Nevada and Iowa.

Ontario alone has a larger GDP than 45 of the 50 US states, and a bigger GDP than New Hampshire, Hawaii, West Virginia, Delaware, Maine, Rhode Island, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Alaska, Wyoming and Vermont put together.


> Ontario alone has a larger GDP than 45 of the 50 US states, and a bigger GDP than New Hampshire, Hawaii, West Virginia, Delaware, Maine, Rhode Island, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Alaska, Wyoming and Vermont put together.

This is not correct as of 2024. In 2024, Ontario had a GDP of CAD 1.17B. [1] In USD, this is (at .73 exchange rate, which is favorable for these calculations) this comes to US 854B.

In 2024, the following US states had greater GDPs [2]: California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Georgia, and tied with Washington. GDP growth in 2025 was worse for Ontario than these states, and it would be expected Ontarios' position to continue to decline.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontario

[2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/248023/us-gross-domestic...


The dollar losing its value probably makes it correct again now since early 2025.


The dollar strengthened against the CAD in 2025 compared to the figures I used. It really only weakened against the EUR and RMB.


January 1st 2025: $1 USD = $1.44 CAD

January 28th 2026: $1 USD = $1.36 CAD

Seems like the USD weakened against the CAD too no?


The figures I provided are for 2024. You would need to compare USD/CAD ratios for 2024 versus 2025. Annual GDP figures for 2026 are not yet available as 2026 has not yet come to pass, so usage of 2026 data is not accurate in this context. To compare, I would consider USD/CAD on December 31, 2024 which was 1.386 [.72] and USD/CAD on December 31, 2025 which was 1.4359 [.69] which are both less favorable than the .73 given.

As stated above, the usage of more accurate figures would render Ontario with a lower GDP than more states.


I am pretty sure many in Minnesota right now would love to be able to exit the current fascist regime and be part of Canada instead ...


Canada isn't coming to save you. Get your own house in order before it burns ours down.


What's is your argument? That tech companies don't need them? Sounds like such a brutally myopic american take.


I see it more like calling out passive racism by these companies.


Looks like the healthcare system.


Looks like a pipeline.


This.


> Democrats need to listen to their own rhetoric and actually take the threat seriously, instead of seeing an opportunity to win a narrow partisan victory for their extremists.

I'm wondering what you call "their extremists". Seen from Europe all Republican candidates are extremists, and Democrats are centrists at best.


> I'm wondering what you call "their extremists".

The deep blue ones who demand everyone check all their boxes.

> Seen from Europe all Republican candidates are extremists, and Democrats are centrists at best.

That seems like a warmed-over 90s perspective that's long past its sell-by. Aren't there "far right" parties in power or nearly in power in much of Europe, and at least one European country that's totally dominated by one?


> That seems like a warmed-over 90s perspective that's long past its sell-by. Aren't there "far right" parties in power or nearly in power in much of Europe, and at least one European country that's totally dominated by one?

Not even close. European politics is by design coalition politics there is no voting blue or red, you are voting for a party and if party has certain amount of votes it will get into parliament (except UK).

The thing is that you would need absurd amount of votes to get more than half of seats in parliament and govern as a single party. So what is normal in USA (one party rule) is exceptionally rare in Europe.

So even if you "win" elections, you need to establish coalitions with less extreme parties to actually achieve majority in government and to be able to modify laws. This will average out your program and will cut down extreme edges on both sides.


Europe is not having terror groups beating and shooting liberal cities.


Dont dream. Even if this project is successful, the protocol may be open but the API keys will only be available to Google, OpenAI & co through complicated deals. You'll never be able to use them.


Someone with 300TB of free storage and a "chaotic" alignment could download a particular archive containing the whole Spotify shebang. And then run a Jellyfin instance around this archive. That would work quite well.

Of course I wouldn't approve of such a procedure.


is the torrent already out? asking for a friend


Indeed Max was involved in the "new app" trainwreck. And was subsequently fired from Sonos along with Patrick. (Source : I also have been fired with several hundreds others because of that fiasco ; you can guess I'm somewhat bitter)


I bet you'll understand when you get older.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: