Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | aucisson_masque's commentslogin

you can do that or you can use free, open source solution like firefly. Accessible from everywhere, has backup options, automatic import data from bank account.

To me, the choice is very easy.


Ublock light is pretty good on Safari

Not compared to the uBlock Origin. You can't even import a filter list. Main reason I use Firefox.

Firefox on iOS has 0 support for Adblocking, making it hell to use.

Something that [1] AdGuard Browser Extension can do, it make you wonder why uBOL can't include such a feature.

[1] https://adguard.com/en/blog/adguard-browser-extension-v5-2.h...


I remember when I was a kid I listened to radio until very late in to the night.

Unless they want to remove all of technology from 10pm to 8am, this bill is going to be ridiculous. Teenager and kid will always find better things to do than sleep.


Famously, there's no point banning kids from buying alcohol because sometimes adults buy it for them.

I’d rather stay far away from this parallel universe.

Why would you want my money to be used to build datacenter that won’t benefit me ? I might use a LLM once a month, many people never use it.

Let the one who use it pay for it.


You are already paying for several national lab HPC centers. These are used for government/university research - no idea if commercial interests can rent time on them. The big ones are running weather, astronomy simulations, nuclear explosions, biological sequencing, and so on.

The biggest run classified nuclear stockpile loads, at least in the US. They cost about half a billion apiece. And are 30 (carefully cooled and cabled) megawatts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Capitan_(supercomputer)

No chance they're going to take risks to share that hardware with anyone given what it does.

The scaled down version of El Capitan is used for non-classified workloads, some of which are proprietary, like drug simulation. It is called Tuolumne. Not long ago, it was nevertheless still a top ten supercomputer.

Like OP, I also don't see why a government supercomputer does it better than hyperscalers, coreweave, neoclouds, et al, who have put in a ton of capital as even compared to government. For loads where institutional continuity is extremely important, like weather -- and maybe one day, a public LLM model or three -- maybe. But we're not there yet, and there's so much competition in LLM infrastructure that it's quite likely some of these entrants will be bag holders, not a world of juicy margins at all...rather, playing chicken with negative gross margins.


>The big ones are running weather, astronomy simulations, nuclear explosions, biological sequencing, and so on.

these things constitute public goods that benefit the individual regardless of participation.


Many more people materially benefit from e.g. good weather forecasts than form video slop generation.

if datacenters are built by the government, then i think it's fair to assume there will be some level of democratic control of what those datacenters will be used for.

What's the democratic control of existing resources? I would make the opposite assumption, it would be captured by the wealthiest interests.

This is literally the current system... adding more democratic controls is a good thing, the alternative is that only rich control these systems and would you look at it only the rich control these systems.

Uncanny really.


Certainly! Your congress representatives would be voting on how to allocate its computing power. (Do you remember who did you vote for last time?)

Sure. Same for healthcare and education right? If you don't have a child or need medical attention, why should you pay for them?

That's like every government initiative. Same as healthcare? School? I mean if you don't have children why do you pay taxes... and roads if you don't drive? I mean the examples are so many... why do you bring this argument that if it doesn't benefit you directly right now today, it shouldn't be done?

There are arguments aplenty that schooling and a minimum amount of healthcare are public goods, as are roads built on public land (the government owns most roads after all).

What is the justification for considering data centers capable of running LLMs to be a public good?

There are many counter examples of things many people use but are still private. Clothing stores, restaurants and grocery stores, farms, home appliance factories, cell phone factories, laundromats and more.


Libraries with books are likely considered public goods right?

Why not an LLM datacenter if it also offers information? You could say it's the public library of the future maybe.


Not all libraries are publicly owned or accessible. Most are run by local municipalities because they wouldn't exist otherwise.

Data centers clearly can exist without being owned by the public.


So can bookstores.

a distinction: the data centers have become the means of production, unlike clothing from a store

How is that distinct from any of my other examples which listed factories? Very few factories in the US are publicly owned; citing data centers as places of production merely furthers the argument that they should remain private.

Healthcare, schools, roads, generative AI. One of these things is not like the others.

We gave incentives to broadband, why not generative AI?

Last-mile services like roads, electricity, water, and telecommunications are natural monopolies. Normal market forces fail somewhat and you want some government involvement to keep it running smoothly.

This is not at all true of generative AI.


I have no idea why you're being downvoted because you're right. The entire point of taxation is to spread the cost among everyone, and since everyone doesn't utilise every government service every tax payer ends up paying for stuff they don't use. That like, the whole point...

I don’t know why you think this is an edgy comment, I’m actually screenshotting it to take a look tomorrow at the links. I’ve seen Anna archive and SCI hub which are extremely useful, if it helps finding more gems I’m all for it !

You're screenshotting URLs to type out?

I do that on my phone. It's almost as easy to tap an ocr-ed url in my photos app as it is to click a link on a web page.

(On my laptop, I'm just as likely to spend half a day writing a scraper or reverse engineering the javascript and apis to collect a dozen or two urls that I should have just jotted down in my notebook...)


This is probably the best innovation in the last decade as far as I’m concerned.

It has conquered the 20 digit WiFi password in 6 font.


why type, when you can copy and paste text from images these days??

It read that way to me too. It's the familiar switcheroo/hoist by their own petard/ironic one-upping move, a routine as well known to the internet as ape behavior is to Jane Goodall.

Agree, ran a business for years and I’ve seen the slow but steady decline of Google ads.

Ultimately I relied more on returning customer and mouth to mouth recommendations, kept lowering the Google ads budget.


Technically you don't even need a flip phone to disconnect from the media and the news. Plenty of people have smartphone but choose not to care about what happens in the world, at least what we have no say in it.

Although if I was American, I think I'd be pretty interested (worried) in what my country is becoming under Trump presidency.

But then, until the elections there is not much one can do.


> obscure (small one-person cars)

I believe it's called motorbike or scooter. Very popular in Asia.


also Europe. Everywhere but in the USA where there's no other transport options besides the road. Makes no sense whatsoever.

That ain't exactly a study as people think of, something scientist do and that get published in a journal, peer reviewed, approved, etc.

It's just kapwing employee checking YouTube channel views and reporting it, same for the feed, so I can't say that the 21-33% number can be trusted.

Now the fact that YouTube has ai slop isn't new, but my bet is that many of these 'subscriber' are in fact bots used to inflate their numbers.

And on a more personal touch, I suggest you install YouTube unhook extension to your computer AND the ones of your relatives. The one less tech savvy that are the more susceptible to fall for this. I surprised my father once watching these kind of crap, he couldn't understand it wasnt even human made. Now I know he's safe from at least that.


> The Gulag Archipelago

I did read it a few years ago, that's very though and it describes in a very technical way how gulags worked. In hindsight I'm not sure it was the best way to do it.

If you liked it tho, id suggest the two kravchenko books on the trials, Rudolph Hess book (very interesting), Simon Sebag Montefiore book on Stalin.

I can provide many more about this kind of subject, I found that fascinating for a few months and did read a lot of books on it.

Although I'd argue that the most fascinating is watching the usa, from outside, turn into a totalitarian state. That is truly incredible to be able to witness how much Trump achieved in a few months.


Thanks for the suggestions, added. And yes, I concur sadly...

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: